NPSL
 
MS
Erie Commodores
Steel City
1
1
 
MS
Michigan Rangers
Erie Commodores
0
0
 
MS
Erie Commodores
Flower City Union
2
3
 
MS
Erie Commodores
Niagara 1812
5
0
ADVERTISEMENTS
 
MS
Erie Commodores
SI Guardians
7
1
 
MS
Steel City
Erie Commodores
2
2
 
MS
Cleveland SC
Erie Commodores
3
2
 
MS
Flower City Union
Erie Commodores
2
2
 
MS
Niagara 1812
Erie Commodores
1
4
 
MS
Erie Commodores
Akron City
2
3