US Open Cup
 
Final
Atlanta United
Indy Eleven
1
2
 USL Championship
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Loudoun United
1
1
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Tampa Bay Rowdies
0
2
 
Final
FC Tulsa
Indy Eleven
0
0
ADVERTISEMENTS
 
Final
Charleston Battery
Indy Eleven
5
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Rhode Island
1
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
New Mexico United
1
3
 
Final
Las Vegas Lights
Indy Eleven
3
2
 US Open Cup
 
Final
Sporting KC
Indy Eleven
2
0
 USL Championship
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Pittsburgh Riverhounds
1
1
 
Final
Hartford Athletic
Indy Eleven
0
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
El Paso Locomotive
3
1
 
Final
North Carolina
Indy Eleven
2
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Miami FC
4
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Louisville City
2
2
 
Final
Loudoun United
Indy Eleven
0
1
 
Final
Detroit City
Indy Eleven
0
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Birmingham Legion
3
2
 
Final
Tampa Bay Rowdies
Indy Eleven
3
0
 
Final
Indy Eleven
Rhode Island
2
3